Blog

Compliment or Critique?

 

THE SLIPPERY SLOPE

Who doesn’t love a compliment? Happy feelings, a sense of accomplishment. 

 

In the artificial world of social media, however, we’ve become Pavlovian experiments, trained to start salivating over “likes” and “shares.” After posting, we refresh the feed just to count how many responses we’ve gotten, which we then translate into whether people like us or not, whether we belong and are accomplished. 

 

As visual artists, this constant need for praise can lead to overconfidence in our work. It can also lower the motivation to improve. The desire for “likes” overwhelms and confuses the mind, creating a sense of failure if your next painting posted doesn’t get the same number of hearts.

 

Honest critiques, on the other hand, are a necessary part of the creative process; they provide internal motivating factors for improvement.

 

The catch:critiques can be demoralizing, if proffered in a way that is hurtful or that we interpret as hurtful, whether it was meant to be or not.

 

TAKING IT WRONG

My buddy, Scott W. Prior, a highly respected painter dude, made the following comment on a recent Instagram post of mine:

“Another pretty painting.” 

I’m not going to lie: I took offense. My first thought was that he was dismissing my work by calling it “pretty.” Scott’s work is gritty and bold. He paints graffiti-filled environments, mosh pits, and amazingly orchestrated paintings of nightlife and urban scenes. He is unabashedly himself. He’s real and raw even when he paints pretty things.

 

Standing Room Only by Scott W. Prior

But the more I thought about it, the more I started to wonder: does my interpretation of someone’s intention depend on who they are or would I take offense no matter what because, really, this is about me and how I receive the message?

 

Here's another comment that gets under my skin: 

“Wow, that looks like a photograph!”  

 

This is usually said by casual observers and meant, I know, as praise. I get it, they don’t know much about art, just what they like. And it’s cool to them that someone can make a painting that looks like a photograph. But still, internally, I take offense, not because I think photography is a lesser art form, but because creating in a photorealistic manner is not my intent. 

HOW WOULD THEY KNOW?

Whether Scott was complimenting the painting I shared on Instagram or dissing it, the insecurity I felt was because of how I see my work. And it’s about my expectations of how I want others to see my work. The word “pretty” pressed an emotional hot button for me. Scott unknowingly tapped into my desire to push-the-envelope, to be more raw, and triggered my fear of letting myself do it.

 

This is not the first time a comment or suggestion to push-the-envelope has tripped me up. My beautiful, talented and like-hearted friend, Rose Fredrick: curator, writer, strategist, has encouraged me over the years to explore and experiment more. She offers a safe place to share new ideas. But every time this comes up, I freeze. I dip a toe in the water, panic, then go back to what I am comfortable with, my happy place.

 

Rose Fredrick-curator, writer, strategist

I just read this great post by Rose this morning about how to adapt to change: Embrace Change Like an Artist. Any of her posts are thought-provoking and informative. You will love the way she thinks, I promise!

In that blog, Rose cites this line from an article in the SAGE Journal titled An Analysis of Resistance to Change Exposed in Individuals’ Thoughts and Behaviors, by Lena M. Forsell and Jan A. Astrom: 

 

“all psychological resistance is built on a fear of change where

the outcome could result in a worse situation.”

 

BUSTED

I recognize in myself that I fear failure, of not being good enough. This makes me internally reactive to even the most off-handed comments, good or bad, because deep down I believe I don’t deserve praise or attention, that I’m a fraud.

I suspect I’m not alone and that, compliment or critique, either way, it comes down to how we receive it. And what we do with it. Not who delivers it.

 

Having a good sense of self is important for growth as an artist, not to mention as a human. I can’t control my initial feelings, but I can dig deeper to understand why I feel that way. Recognizing these emotions allows me to push through self doubt.

UPPING MY GAME

I’ve worked hard at my craft, and acknowledge the wonderful successes that have come my way. But I also recognize that there is still more work to do to get better. I think Seth Grodin said it well in his blog, Could Be Better: 

 

 

In other words, no matter who delivers the compliment or offers the critique–even if it’s self analysis–we get to choose what we do with that message and how we react.

 

What’s helped me: 

Not let social media define me.

Find trusted sources for concrete critiques. 

Learn how to evaluate your own work.

Be grateful.

For me, it’s time to up my game, push out of my comfort zone, and walk down an uncharted path. Don’t get me wrong, I’m still doing “pretty,” but there’s some “raw” coming down the trail soon. ;-)


Thanks for reading. Please share your comments below and feel free to share my blog!

If you’re interested in receiving a copy of my tips for self critiquing your own work, sign up for my newsletter and I’ll send you a link: 

The Power of Self Critiques by Kim Lordier

Comments

28 Responses to Compliment or Critique?

So, you are the best pastel artist (IMO) and also a so intelligent person! You make us feel gappy with your art and now with life advices, thank you, deeply thank you Kim!!! Greetings from México City :)

Hey Kim! I would love to have a copy of your Tips for Self-Critique. I have a very difficult time with that!! I already get your newsletter and the form didn't give me another option, so thought I would put it here. Love the new work! For the record, I have never thought that your paintings were just -another pretty painting” or super-realism. They have always represented to me your unique take on whatever scene you are interpreting, giving the viewer a powerful, richer, more visually complex color interpretation of the scenes in front of you. Yes, I find them to be stunningly beautiful! But they certainly are not just -another pretty painting.” Many people can do that - you are painting in another league altogether my friend! So happy we have one of your beautiful works hanging in our home. I hope someday for another one! Love and hugs to you! ❤️ Lynn

Hi Kim, I am already a subscriber but would appreciate your Self Critique ebook. Also, I am SO HAPPY for you for your gorgeous upcoming show!!! The presentation you created to showcase your work and your inspirations is quite moving—I'm sharing it with my family and friends. I truly appreciate your artwork and self analysis. Let me emphasize that your pastels go WAY beyond pretty! Melody

Amen, my friend. Appreciate you writing this. Every word resonates.

Hi Betty, Greetings from California! You are the nicest! Thank you so much for your comment here. I'm happy that some of my getting personal stuff is tapping into your life. So, you are the best pastel artist (IMO) and also a so intelligent person! You make us feel gappy with your art and now with life advices, thank you, deeply thank you Kim!!! Greetings from México City :)

Hi Lynn! I just sent you and email with my ebook: The Power of Self Critiques. Any feedback, re: critique, would be welcome! Love ya, K Hey Kim! I would love to have a copy of your Tips for Self-Critique. I have a very difficult time with that!! I already get your newsletter and the form didn't give me another option, so thought I would put it here. Love the new work! For the record, I have never thought that your paintings were just -another pretty painting” or super-realism. They have always represented to me your unique take on whatever scene you are interpreting, giving the viewer a powerful, richer, more visually complex color interpretation of the scenes in front of you. Yes, I find them to be stunningly beautiful! But they certainly are not just -another pretty painting.” Many people can do that - you are painting in another league altogether my friend! So happy we have one of your beautiful works hanging in our home. I hope someday for another one! Love and hugs to you! ❤️ Lynn

Hi Melody! So great to hear from you! I just sent you and email with my ebook: The Power of Self Critiques. Thank you for taking the time to share your thoughts here! Happy painting to you, my friend! --------------------------------------------------------------------------- Hi Kim, I am already a subscriber but would appreciate your Self Critique ebook. Also, I am SO HAPPY for you for your gorgeous upcoming show!!! The presentation you created to showcase your work and your inspirations is quite moving””I'm sharing it with my family and friends. I truly appreciate your artwork and self analysis. Let me emphasize that your pastels go WAY beyond pretty! Melody

Hi Liz! Thank you my friend! Appreciate you taking the time to read the post. Hope IAPS was awesome. Sad to have missed it.... Hope our paths cross soon. ------------------------------------------------------------------- Amen, my friend. Appreciate you writing this. Every word resonates.

Your words always manage to resonate, whether they are about art or life. So glad you share your gift of insight in art and the world. Looking forward to seeing what you come up with next! Also - will any of your newest work be available for viewing at Rieser Fine Art prior to your reception?

Really heart felt Kim! And I can totally relate to your feelings.. I'm certain that all of us experience this at some point. Beautifully written. Thank you for being so transparent. You will surely bring comfort to many❤️

Thank you so much, Kathy. I am hoping Jim at Rieser Fine Art will be putting the show paintings up on his website by the end of this week. I will be dropping them off on Friday. Love you! ----------------------------------------------------- Your words always manage to resonate, whether they are about art or life. So glad you share your gift of insight in art and the world. Looking forward to seeing what you come up with next! Also - will any of your newest work be available for viewing at Rieser Fine Art prior to your reception?

Hi Rita, Thank you very much for taking the time to share your thoughts here. I am finding it a bit liberating to share personal stuff on this blog. Has really helped my inner dialog. Happy painting to you! ------------------------------------------------ Really heart felt Kim! And I can totally relate to your feelings.. I'm certain that all of us experience this at some point. Beautifully written. Thank you for being so transparent. You will surely bring comfort to many❤️

Love this post, Kim. Your candor, vulnerability, and authenticity are refreshing and inspiring. And I love the summary four points at the end. Having started painting as late in life as I did, I need all the candid, quality feedback I can garner, especially from myself. And gratitude helps everything! 🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻ðŸ'™ Looking forward to reading through your self-critique guidance. And I'm also looking forward to your forthcoming raw and gritty paintings! Cheers from the Netherlands.

Hi Kim, I would love to have a copy of your ebook. As in music, I feel insecure and sensitive about critiques and want to get better at evaluating my work. Thank you!

I really needed to read this article today. I have only been in this -game” for a few years, and have grown somewhat, but there is so much road ahead, and I need this encouragement to keep on growing and trying new ideas. We were in the Halifax Art Gallery yesterday, and looking at a particular piece, and my wife said, -You paint like that.”. I was taken back somewhat, flattered, but also concerned. Am I stuck in a rut? I had better get my creative thinking cap on. This morning, your article has really resonated with me.

Kim, you definitely hit the nail on the head with your comments on how to receive, how to feel, what to do with, etc. words about the work we do. It always cracks me up when I hear: "It looks like a photograph." and I cringe, but smile knowing it is meant as praise... from someone that does not understand about producing art that is a "feeling" we have, not a replication. And, another pretty painting ... not exactly what our aim usually is. Some do though! But, I want more than that as you do as well. Love all you had to say because it comes from your heartfelt desire to add your take on the world by painting it. I've struggled, though I've had fun as well, the last number of years to figure out exactly how I want to proceed, why and what I want to paint, etc. I love it every day! Love you, girlfriend, and sad I don't get to see you to talk and laugh! ... and paint plein air!

You nailed it. This struggle is real and the pressures I have really placed on myself are bumped up by social media. That fear of change is real for me as well. I have worked hard to learn to paint as I do but I am dissatisfied now and want to move on, but what if everyone hates it! Man I get all you wrote. Well put your words would apply to writers, creators in any media.

Jeff, thank you! Not sure how "gritty" things will be. LOL But I'm working on some stuff that feels like it has to come out... I think the nature of our "climate" is wearing thin right now, and this is how I am able to respond to it. It is actually empowering on a certain level. You keep doin' whatcha doin" Follow your heart and your truth. You've got a lot to give. Cheers from California! ------------------------------------------------------------------- Love this post, Kim. Your candor, vulnerability, and authenticity are refreshing and inspiring. And I love the summary four points at the end. Having started painting as late in life as I did, I need all the candid, quality feedback I can garner, especially from myself. And gratitude helps everything! ð?™ð?»ð?™ð?»ð?™ð?»ð?'™ Looking forward to reading through your self-critique guidance. And I'm also looking forward to your forthcoming raw and gritty paintings! Cheers from the Netherlands. Posted by Jeff Eickhoff · via kimfancherlordier.com · 21 hours ago

Hi Suzanne, I've taken the liberty to send you a personal email in regards to this comment. Hope you don't mind. --------------------------------------------------------------- Hi Kim, I would love to have a copy of your ebook. As in music, I feel insecure and sensitive about critiques and want to get better at evaluating my work. Thank you!

Hi Marsha! I just sent you a lengthy email with a reply and the critique book. I know you already know all the tricks in there. But sometimes, it is fun to refresh the memory. I sure appreciate you taking the time to read through the blog and comment. Love you, K ------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Kim, you definitely hit the nail on the head with your comments on how to receive, how to feel, what to do with, etc. words about the work we do. It always cracks me up when I hear: "It looks like a photograph." and I cringe, but smile knowing it is meant as praise... from someone that does not understand about producing art that is a "feeling" we have, not a replication. And, another pretty painting ... not exactly what our aim usually is. Some do though! But, I want more than that as you do as well. Love all you had to say because it comes from your heartfelt desire to add your take on the world by painting it. I've struggled, though I've had fun as well, the last number of years to figure out exactly how I want to proceed, why and what I want to paint, etc. I love it every day! Love you, girlfriend, and sad I don't get to see you to talk and laugh! ... and paint plein air!

Thank you for sharing, Cindy. It's hard to say it out loud in front of people let alone inside our heads. I'm glad this post resonated with you. I think, bottom line, it's most important how YOU like what you do. Because, in the doing is where the love happens. It can be little steps, doesn't have to be a huge leap. Mine are little steps, and it has been liberating so far! ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------- You nailed it. This struggle is real and the pressures I have really placed on myself are bumped up by social media. That fear of change is real for me as well. I have worked hard to learn to paint as I do but I am dissatisfied now and want to move on, but what if everyone hates it! Man I get all you wrote. Well put your words would apply to writers, creators in any media.

Hi John, So very glad this post resonated with you. I appreciate your share here. I wrote you a note via email. Hope you don't mind. In the meantime, enjoy road, ruts, dead-end, and majestic vistas along the way! ----------------------------------------------- I really needed to read this article today. I have only been in this -game” for a few years, and have grown somewhat, but there is so much road ahead, and I need this encouragement to keep on growing and trying new ideas. We were in the Halifax Art Gallery yesterday, and looking at a particular piece, and my wife said, -You paint like that.”. I was taken back somewhat, flattered, but also concerned. Am I stuck in a rut? I had better get my creative thinking cap on. This morning, your article has really resonated with me.

Kim, you are so brave and beautiful to speak the words we all feel. There is truth in every word of this post. It's exhausting, working on myself, to clear the voices in my head (and on social media). The only reason I don't give up is because I know it's worth the battle. Your friendship means the world to me, and we must talk more often. I'm only worried that if I share all of my doubts it would also have a negative effect on you. Thank you for your love. ❤️

Lori Putnam! I'm going to call you right now. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ Kim, you are so brave and beautiful to speak the words we all feel. There is truth in every word of this post. It's exhausting, working on myself, to clear the voices in my head (and on social media). The only reason I don't give up is because I know it's worth the battle. Your friendship means the world to me, and we must talk more often. I'm only worried that if I share all of my doubts it would also have a negative effect on you. Thank you for your love. ❤️

Hi Kim, I found reading your newsletter very helpful and encouraging to hear we all go through times of questioning our art work. It is comforting to now I am not alone. I think I could benefit from your self critique book if you could send that to me. Thank you! I really admire your paintings. I always feel that I get a certain feeling when viewing them. Its not just the outstanding craftsmanship that you have but that you capture a mood, or certain time of day, and/or what it felt like to be there that draws me in. I hope someday to study with you. I won't be able to make to all your upcoming shows but I do plan to go to Bowers Museum. It will be a treat to see your work in real life. With warmth, Robin

You inspire me, Kim. I'm grateful for your friendship and your ability to be real and raw--and pretty--all at once. :) Thanks for including me in your blog. Hope it's OK if I share with my subscribers; you're spot-on and are writing about things that we all deal with. Hugs! Rose

Hi Robin, I'm so glad that you found some comfort in this post. I really appreciate your kind words about my work. I hope you were able to get to the Bower's Museum for the Gold Medal show. It looks so beautiful online. Unfortunately, I couldn't attend the opening. 'Til our paths cross, Happy Painting! Kim ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Hi Kim, I found reading your newsletter very helpful and encouraging to hear we all go through times of questioning our art work. It is comforting to now I am not alone. I think I could benefit from your self critique book if you could send that to me. Thank you! I really admire your paintings. I always feel that I get a certain feeling when viewing them. Its not just the outstanding craftsmanship that you have but that you capture a mood, or certain time of day, and/or what it felt like to be there that draws me in. I hope someday to study with you. I won't be able to make to all your upcoming shows but I do plan to go to Bowers Museum. It will be a treat to see your work in real life. With warmth, Robin

This article is so sincere, and I completely agree with what is written. As an emerging artist I had to first win my first battle in life of finding some sort of identity as an artist. I was very discouraged at young age NOT to be an artist. If I did not rekindle this passion of mine of self-discovery, I would not be feeling a sense of achievement is my work. Self-doubts crips in all the time. I need to stay away often rom social media if I want to find my voice. I get excited because I can finally BE an artist. But that requires a big shoe to fill. Where am I really going? What are my weakness as an artist and how do I improve? This article is very inspiring and is what I need it to hear! So, Thank you!


Leave a Comment

Remember Your Info
Check this box if you want email updates when people comment on this post