Blog
Compliment or Critique?

THE SLIPPERY SLOPE
Who doesn’t love a compliment? Happy feelings, a sense of accomplishment.

In the artificial world of social media, however, we’ve become Pavlovian experiments, trained to start salivating over “likes” and “shares.” After posting, we refresh the feed just to count how many responses we’ve gotten, which we then translate into whether people like us or not, whether we belong and are accomplished.
As visual artists, this constant need for praise can lead to overconfidence in our work. It can also lower the motivation to improve. The desire for “likes” overwhelms and confuses the mind, creating a sense of failure if your next painting posted doesn’t get the same number of hearts.
Honest critiques, on the other hand, are a necessary part of the creative process; they provide internal motivating factors for improvement.

The catch:critiques can be demoralizing, if proffered in a way that is hurtful or that we interpret as hurtful, whether it was meant to be or not.
TAKING IT WRONG
My buddy, Scott W. Prior, a highly respected painter dude, made the following comment on a recent Instagram post of mine:
“Another pretty painting.”
I’m not going to lie: I took offense. My first thought was that he was dismissing my work by calling it “pretty.” Scott’s work is gritty and bold. He paints graffiti-filled environments, mosh pits, and amazingly orchestrated paintings of nightlife and urban scenes. He is unabashedly himself. He’s real and raw even when he paints pretty things.
Standing Room Only by Scott W. Prior
But the more I thought about it, the more I started to wonder: does my interpretation of someone’s intention depend on who they are or would I take offense no matter what because, really, this is about me and how I receive the message?
Here's another comment that gets under my skin:
“Wow, that looks like a photograph!”

This is usually said by casual observers and meant, I know, as praise. I get it, they don’t know much about art, just what they like. And it’s cool to them that someone can make a painting that looks like a photograph. But still, internally, I take offense, not because I think photography is a lesser art form, but because creating in a photorealistic manner is not my intent.
HOW WOULD THEY KNOW?
Whether Scott was complimenting the painting I shared on Instagram or dissing it, the insecurity I felt was because of how I see my work. And it’s about my expectations of how I want others to see my work. The word “pretty” pressed an emotional hot button for me. Scott unknowingly tapped into my desire to push-the-envelope, to be more raw, and triggered my fear of letting myself do it.
This is not the first time a comment or suggestion to push-the-envelope has tripped me up. My beautiful, talented and like-hearted friend, Rose Fredrick: curator, writer, strategist, has encouraged me over the years to explore and experiment more. She offers a safe place to share new ideas. But every time this comes up, I freeze. I dip a toe in the water, panic, then go back to what I am comfortable with, my happy place.
Rose Fredrick-curator, writer, strategist
I just read this great post by Rose this morning about how to adapt to change: Embrace Change Like an Artist. Any of her posts are thought-provoking and informative. You will love the way she thinks, I promise!
In that blog, Rose cites this line from an article in the SAGE Journal titled An Analysis of Resistance to Change Exposed in Individuals’ Thoughts and Behaviors, by Lena M. Forsell and Jan A. Astrom:
“all psychological resistance is built on a fear of change where
the outcome could result in a worse situation.”
BUSTED
I recognize in myself that I fear failure, of not being good enough. This makes me internally reactive to even the most off-handed comments, good or bad, because deep down I believe I don’t deserve praise or attention, that I’m a fraud.
I suspect I’m not alone and that, compliment or critique, either way, it comes down to how we receive it. And what we do with it. Not who delivers it.
Having a good sense of self is important for growth as an artist, not to mention as a human. I can’t control my initial feelings, but I can dig deeper to understand why I feel that way. Recognizing these emotions allows me to push through self doubt.
UPPING MY GAME
I’ve worked hard at my craft, and acknowledge the wonderful successes that have come my way. But I also recognize that there is still more work to do to get better. I think Seth Grodin said it well in his blog, Could Be Better:
In other words, no matter who delivers the compliment or offers the critique–even if it’s self analysis–we get to choose what we do with that message and how we react.
What’s helped me:
Not let social media define me.
Find trusted sources for concrete critiques.
Learn how to evaluate your own work.
Be grateful.
For me, it’s time to up my game, push out of my comfort zone, and walk down an uncharted path. Don’t get me wrong, I’m still doing “pretty,” but there’s some “raw” coming down the trail soon. ;-)
Thanks for reading. Please share your comments below and feel free to share my blog!
If you’re interested in receiving a copy of my tips for self critiquing your own work, sign up for my newsletter and I’ll send you a link:










28 Responses to Compliment or Critique?
Leave a Comment